City market report

Shelter Island, NY Housing Market Trends

Shelter Island, NY, across 2 ZIP codes, has a typical home value of $1.96M, +5.3% over the past 12 months and +41.6% over 5 years.

All homes

$1.96M

+1.2%

+5.3%

+41.6%

10Y

+97.8%

Single family

$1.98M

+1.2%

+5.1%

+41.9%

10Y

+97.5%

Loading map…

For agents with past clients here

Have clients who bought in Shelter Island between 2015 and 2022?

A typical home here has gained about $577K in the last five years alone. Touchpoint sends them a branded, updated home value report so you stay the agent they think of. Setup takes a couple of minutes.

Try it free for 14 days See a sample report →

All Shelter Island ZIP codes

ZIP	City	All homes	Single family	Condo	12-month	5-year
11965	Shelter Island	$2.11M	$2.13M	n/a	+6.2%	+43.6%
11964	Shelter Island	$1.82M	$1.83M	n/a	+4.4%	+39.6%

Nearby cities

Sagaponack housing market Water Mill housing market Bridgehampton housing market Wainscott housing market Amagansett housing market Quogue housing market Sag Harbor housing market Southampton housing market

Typical home values are medians of ZIP-level home value index data. This is market data, not an appraisal, broker price opinion or CMA.

Know homeowners in Shelter Island, NY? Show them what their home is worth.

Touchpoint sends your past clients and sphere a branded monthly home value report, automatically, so you are the agent they call when it is time to sell.

Start free 14-day trial See pricing